Hiring

Why HVAC Companies Push a Replacement Instead of a Repair

A gas furnace with the closet door open
Photo: The EnergySmart Academy

A furnace that will not start does not always need a new furnace. A lot of the estimates still come back that way. The technician is in the basement for twenty minutes, and the only number on the page is for a system, not for a part.

The commission is on the new system

On a larger company, the person in the house is often paid a commission when they sell a replacement. A capacitor, a control board, or a blower motor is an hour of labor. A new furnace or air conditioner is the check they went out hoping to write. Nobody has to tell them to skip the repair. The pay already did.

The shop makes its money on the box

Those companies buy equipment by the truckload, and the margin is on that equipment. A repair does not fill an install crew for a day. So the visit leans toward a new system. The unit is old. Parts will be hard to find. The efficiency will pay for itself. Some of that is true of a 25-year-old furnace with a cracked heat exchanger. It is not true of a 12-year-old air conditioner with a bad capacitor.

An owner wants to be called again

An independent contractor is the person who has to live with the job. Sell a system the house did not need, and the neighbor hears about it. The next call does not come from that street. They would rather repair it and be asked back. A part that puts the heat or the cooling back on is the work. They replace the system when it is actually finished, not because the truck needs the sale.

When a replacement is the right call

A cracked heat exchanger is not a repair. A compressor that failed on an old air conditioner often is not either, once you price the part against what the unit has left. Ask for both numbers before you sign, the repair and the replacement, and ask which one they would put on their own house. If the only paper they brought is for a new system, that is the answer.

The shops on this list are owner-operated. You call the shop. The person who quotes the work is not paid a commission to sell you a box.

More in Hiring